How students are painting Montreal red

More

Felt Red Square

Felt red square, via Free Education Montreal


My friends at Waging Nonviolence have been putting together some amazing articles about successful nonviolent movements from the past and present, with a hope that today’s activists can learn from history and current actions. I was intrigued when I was sent this article about the “Red Square” movement in Canada.
Started because of increases in tuition, the movement is rapidly growing and judging from reports of mass arrests, beatings, and pepper spraying, it is starting to really annoy the powers that be. While our friends to the north are complaining about “staggering” student debts of nearly $30,000, US students are facing debts of hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Both sides of the border are feeling the pain and more and more young people are starting to stand up. Read more to get an on-the-ground perspective from recent actions in Montreal.

How students are painting Montreal red

On Wednesday night in Montreal, we shared a long dinner with student organizers, discussing everything from police tactics in Montreal and New York to the necessity of an anti-racist and anti-colonial framework for our movements. Our hosts noticed that, around the time that the nightly 8:30 p.m. march was supposed to begin, we were getting nervous about missing it. They laughed and said, “Don’t worry, it will go on until 2 a.m.” Or at least they normally do.
By midnight, after peacefully and joyfully marching through the city for hours, the police charged our march of about 4,000 people with batons and pepper spray. In a moment the scene became one of chaos and confusion. Many in the crowd turned around and ran, but there were police behind us, too, coming straight at us with their batons out as people were pepper sprayed and thrown to the ground. Eventually, we found our way out of the melée and asked our Canadian comrade what had happened to provoke the police. “Nothing,” she answered. “They just got tired of us.”
We had been lucky. Moments after the police charged us, they surrounded a group of 506 protesters and arrested everyone in what became the largest single mass arrest since the indefinite student strike began here in Quebec 103 days ago.
The student movement in Quebec is growing. On Tuesday, an estimated 300,000 to 400,000 students, workers and supporters took to the streets to protest tuition hikes and the passing of the new, draconian anti-protest law – Law 78 – as well as to celebrate the 100th day of the student strike. But state repression is also growing. Last night’s mass arrest and other forms of police violence bear witness to the new climate of fear and repression that the Charest government is trying to create in order to break the student movement.
The passing of Law 78 is a direct attack on the freedom of assembly and the right to protest. It not only bans unpermitted marches or any unpermitted gathering of more than 50 people, but the vaguely worded “special law” also threatens to levy enormous fines against organizers, unions and potentially anyone who participates in an unpermitted assembly. The law comes in response to the growing popularity of the student movement and can be read as as symptom of the government’s inability to control the movement; it is a sign that in some ways the students are winning. In fact, since its passage last Friday, the nightly marches have only gotten larger as more people see the struggle expanding from the single issue of university tuition to a broader one that includes the right to protest and the suppression of dissent.
The media in the United States have hardly noticed the Quebec student strike, despite it being the longest and largest in the history of North America. Those of us who have been following the movement have been amazed by the sheer numbers that these mass demonstrations have mobilized, with hundreds of thousands taking to the streets on major days of action. What is less known, but equally important, is that every single night for the past month there have been marches of several thousand protesters. These high-energy marches snake their way across the eastern side of the island for hours, through residential and commercial neighborhoods. People in bars, restaurants and apartment windows shout back, wave flags, chant with the protesters and cheer them on, even banging their pots and pans, in reference to the Latin American tradition of cacerolazo protests. The breadth of politicization and the everyday forms of solidarity in Montreal is formidable to witness.
“This didn’t happen overnight”
The prevalence of the red squares that symbolize the student strike is stunning: pinned in the hair of a girl on the metro, worn as earrings by another, attached to a baby carriage, or duct-taped on backpacks, shoes, bike helmets and cell phones. But most of all the small, red felt squares are safety-pinned to people’s jackets or shirts, a visible expression of the crushing student-loan debt that Canadian students face – on average, $27,000, according to the Canadian Federation of Students. They’re derived from to the expression “carrément dans la rouge,” literally translated as “squarely in the red.” They are everyday reminders of the increased burden of debt that will come with increased tuition. So many people are wearing the red squares, some claim that the dollar stores where the red felt is bought are running out of it.
When we express disbelief that one of the biggest universities in Canada, the Universitité du Montréal, has been forced to cancel classes and end its semester early because of the strike, and when we are amazed at the prevalence of red squares, people simply say, “Yes, but we have been working for two years to get here.” And it is true. The tuition hikes have been on the table since 2010, when the tuition freeze ended. In March 2011, Quebec announced its plan to raise tuition by $325 a year over 5 years. In response to this, protesters occupied the finance minister’s office.
When we ask how, over that time, so many students have been mobilized and politicized, the answer is both simple and complex. As student organizer Myriam Zaidi said, “We’ve been standing on corners handing out leaflets and having conversations with people about this for years. Just opening up that space of conversation has been hugely important. This didn’t happen overnight.” These basic forms of disseminating information about the tuition hikes and fostering debate about these issues have been pivotal in mobilizing massive on-the-ground support behind their call for a strike.
But the more complicated answer to our question lies in the organizing structure and history of student unions at universities in Quebec. Organized at a variety of levels – from that of the whole Quebec Province all the way down to individual departments – these unions provide a way for students to organize politically, granting them both legitimacy and power. Longer-term mobilizing strategies include campaigns to build strike votes at general membership meetings, carefully navigated negotiations with governments and university administrations, and coalition-building between the various unions. These have been pivotal in securing a unified front during the current strike. This current round of protests are also only the most recent expressions of a much longer history of radical student unionism in Quebec, which dates back to the 1960s.
Solidarité
All in all this has meant that when, on February 14, the student unions at the Universitié du Montréal called for a strike, they already had a very strong base level of support. From there, picket-lines were organized in front of classrooms, and efforts to shut down the university required constant organizing and action. As one student organizer told us, “In those first few weeks, it was very tedious. We knew the class schedule, and we would stand outside the classrooms with signs … Many students would know this was going on and just stay home … One conservative history professor charged the picket line once.”
The university didn’t take these actions lightly. Our friend went on to describe how, in March, fed up with the picket lines and the strike, the university hired a notorious strike-breaking security firm. Armed guards patrolled its hallways, interrogating people about why they weren’t in class, stopping professors and students alike to bully and harass them. This, however, only lasted a few days until widespread outrage from faculty of all political leanings forced the administration to withdraw the guards. Unbroken, the strike continued to the present, and now the provincial government has called for an early end to the semester in yet another attempt to break it.
There are varying levels of support at different universities and in different parts of Quebec. At the English-speaking, elite McGill University, support has not been as widespread, and an attempted student strike there has not been successful (despite having had an occupation of the administrative offices there in the winter). In some ways, this is emblematic of historic divisions between the French-speaking and English-speaking communities in Montreal and Quebec, and of the way that these divisions also fray along class lines. Occasionally this has meant that the protests have a nationalistic flavor to them, with people carrying the Quebec flag and chanting things like: “A qui le Québec? A nous le Québec!” (Whose Quebec? Our Quebec!)
These nationalist undertones have been increasingly contested by student organizers of color who have been actively working to articulate an anti-racist and anti-colonial analysis within the movement, while also combating the false view that the movement is dominated by white students. These efforts are increasingly successful, as shown by the creation of the students-of-color and anti-racist coalitions that had a presence at Tuesday’s march. (Listen to an interview with one of the organizers here, starting at 23:00.)
During these marches, or while banging pots on street corners with our Montreal comrades, the question often on our minds is how we as students in New York City can stand in solidarity with them. The first answer, of course, is to build our own movement and to build it in explicit connection with the one happening here in Montreal. We too are facing tuition hikes at public schools, from New York to California. We too are met with repression and violence when we express dissent. And, fundamentally, the core issues at stake here are the same ones that students and workers around the world are facing right now: the implementation of austerity measures, the increasing privatization of education and (to use Prime Minister Charest’s unapologetically Thacharist language) a “cultural revolution” in the way we think of education. What was once a common good is being purposefully transformed into an elite commodity available to only those who can afford it.
Last night, as we marched in Montreal, it was with the knowledge that hundreds of our Occupy Wall Street comrades in New York were marching in solidarity for the third time. (Here is video of the first.) Occupy Wall Street itself grew out of solidarity with the Tunisian and Egyptian and Spanish and Greek uprisings, after people began asking themselves, “How dowedothathere?” Our generation of students in the United States has yet to mobilize on a mass scale, but after watching what’s happening up here in Quebec, perhaps that will change.
 
Craig Wiesner posted this article with the permission of the team at Waging Nonviolence. Click here to view the article on their web site.

0 thoughts on “How students are painting Montreal red

  1. I’m happy to see this in Tikkun. My son, a senior at McGill, is in the middle of all this along with hundreds of fellow students from McGill who are choosing to identify in solidarity with all the students of all of Quebec. It is stunning and it strikes me that not only does this have roots in movements that began in the 1960s in Quebec but in France itself. 1968 was a huge year of mobilizations of all kinds there. We might not have notice in U.S. because we were involved in the anti-war civil rights struggles and the upheaval of two assassinations. Much turmoil, much revelation, much progress toward justice.

  2. I live in Montreal, and, yes,politically, the shit is hitting the fan very heavily. The confrontation between mostly radical students and a center-right government over a hike of student fees here is pretty bitter. Of course there is disgusting demagogic saturation condemnation by the bourgeois media of the movement. But who cares what THEY have to say, right?! They exagerate, for instance, all the fringe violence of course ,to discredit us. I personally do NOT support any violence and vandalism (and that from a person who is no pacifist: the situation here is not so bleak as to require any violence, not even close.) With these excesses the Left discredits itself, another example of the Left shooting itself in the foot, with its usual rhetorical and practical excesses. But they, nevertheless, are mainly right about this issue. And, generally, a great awakening and rejuvenation of the Left, young and old, is taking place here and that feels good.

    • Marco – It is great to have perspective from you in Montreal. One of the most important lessons I have learned in my activism is to be as clear and strong as I can, especially trying to avoid rhetoric that isn’t helpful to the cause. And I am deeply committed to nonviolence as are most of the people with whom I work. With politicians here in the US saying that it is “elitist” to encourage college for all, coupled with dramatic cuts in education spending, with the addition of hikes in fees and interest rates on loans… it is NOT rhetorical to say that there is an attack on public education which seems determined to put higher education out of the reach of the masses. Young people should be standing up against this and I’m grateful to see so many are.

  3. Craig- Thanks for your comments.
    One of the future specters that the Quebec striking students evoke to justify their opposition to hikes in students fees is the situation in the United States.Now, in all fairness to the right-wing corrupt government of Quebec, the fees here are the lowest on the continent by far ( policies enacted by previous governments based on a more European model), and they still would be low with a hike compared to the US generally , and Ontario, for instance. Perhaps this issue then is a bit weak as a flashpoint. The advantage of it, on the other hand, is that the university as an institution is loaded with radical students ready to fight the elites, so there are endless demos and activism on this issue and others, day after day after day..night after night after night. The students’ persistence and energy is incredible. They are wearing the government and the police out.The conflict is also opening space to discuss deeper societal issues, so the ideological battle in the mainstream, alternative, and social media is fierce , extensive, and deep. The disadvantage with that is that it can turn violent on both sides. Much to my horror, so many demonstrators have thrown bricks and stones and what not at the police. Very very dangerous . The police do NOT deserve that! Nothing should be done to risk their physical integrity! They in turn have beaten on demonstrators pretty fiercely sometimes. One student lost an eye from a projectile of unknown origin ( the strikers say the police did it; the police say otherwise…naturally…). That has caused me nightmares. Quebec is not Syria! Nothing, to repeat, justifies the least bit of violence from either side, in this situation.No shoving, no rocks, no fists! In Syria, and before in Lybia, and Kosovo, armed conflict was justified to fight off fascism. But not here.
    Let me say further that I have often contested the pacifism of Tikkun and related organisations, and I still do. But I think I understand and respect you people better now , in the midst of this conflict. Although I cannot go to demos here for health reasons, I would choose a pacifist group to hang with as support and protection in a demo, so as to avoid some of the violent crazies who might be lurking about on the street.
    Finally, some late news: Talks between the government and the students have just broken down again today, after 4 days. I don’t know the details yet and what may possibly now happen.The conflict continues…

    • Marco – Thank you again for sharing views and news. Understanding and respect are key to people who hold somewhat different views or vastly different views learning how to get along AND find ways to achieve change together.

  4. Hi again, Craig: Understanding and respect are easy for people who have small differences of opinion; almost impossible for those with vastly different views. I don’t even try with my enemies.Why bother? I’m not into “loving” my enemies. More like Camus: not hating them is a more realistic goal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *