Let’s Give Gay Servicemembers a Christmas Gift – End Don’t Ask Don’t Tell
by: Craig Wiesner on November 30th, 2010 | 2 Comments »
In 1987 I left the United States Air Force after serving honorably for eight years. I couldn’t stand the idea of having to hide who I was, having to live a lonely isolated life, and despite being willing to live without love or true companionship, facing the constant threat of being outed and having my career destroyed.
This week, Congress can help to right a wrong that has destroyed lives, careers, and perpetuated prejudice and discrimination against people who simply wanted to serve their country. The military has spoken and those who serve have said that they want an end to “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell.” Let’s show our military that we listen to them and urge Congress to put an end to this stain on our nation’s honor.
You’ll see a call to action from the Human Rights Campaign at the bottom of this post. Before that I wanted to share my story so that you’ll understand how personal a call it is.
When I joined the Air Force I knew I was gay, but I had decided that I could forgo love in order to have a good career and a chance to go to college. I know now that was an unfair choice to have to make (and a foolish one at that), but I was willing to live that way.
I was an all-star in Basic Training, graduating with honors. My squad leader was a really great guy, who helped everyone in our squad succeed, and I was thrilled when I found out he was also going to be heading to Monterey to learn to be a linguist along with me. A few weeks after we arrived, he was suddenly pulled from class. Someone had told the commander that they thought he was homosexual. That was all it took and a few weeks later he was gone. Career over.
I made it through language school, top of my class, and then soared through the next phase of training in Texas. Arriving in Korea I sailed through on-the-job-training and became one of the youngest supervisors and trainers in the unit’s history. During my second year in Korea I lived through a witch hunt when a fellow linguist decided he couldn’t stay in the closet any longer. He told the commander he was gay and was immediately relived of duty. The hunt was on for who knew he was gay and who else might be gay.
I had told my best friend that I was gay just a few days before this all started. He was also a good friend of the other guy who had come out to the commander. They interrogated my friend, the whole bright light in a dark room thing! They showed him a picture of his parents’ house and asked him if he liked it. “Yeah. I grew up there.” he told them. “Well, it’s too bad your mommy and daddy are going to lose it by the time we’re finished with you. All your legal bills are going to cost them everything they have. They won’t want their little baby to go to jail forever, and that’s where you’re heading if you don’t tell us who else in this unit is a fag.” His response was wonderful. “I know my rights and I know you can’t take away my parents’ house. What you’re doing right now isn’t right. If you want to court martial me, go ahead, but I have nothing more to say to you. Can I leave now?” He could and he did.
Still, once he told me about what had happened, I was terrified.
One afternoon a few days later, when I was getting a replacement badge for entering our unit, the security policeman in charge of guarding our unit started to chat with me as he made my new badge. “Some mess that guy caused around here. Never would have guessed he was a fag.” I didn’t respond to him which perhaps is what prompted him to continue. “Now you… I wonder about you. How come you hardly ever go drinking with the rest of the crowd. I’ve noticed that even if you do go out, you don’t drink very much and you NEVER go home with any of the girls.” The girls he mentioned were the prostitutes that frequented the bars around our base. “You know, in your next assignment you’re heading to Fort Meade, and everyone has to take a lie detector test when they arrive. If you’re a fag, they’re going to find out.”
I asked him to please give me my badge and left. Shortly after that I found out about a job opening to be a language instructor at the Defense Language Institute in Monterey. The good news was I wouldn’t have to renew my security clearance, thus no lie detector test. The bad news was I’d have to reenlist for four years to take the job. I applied, got the job, and reenlisted. For the next four years I stayed completely in the closet and watched as incredibly talented young men and women got pulled out of class and kicked out of the military because they were suspected of being gay. All you had to do was slip a note under an officer’s door saying “So and so is queer.” and that person would be gone. What a waste. What a tragedy. What a crime.
Despite early promotions, medals, a very promising career, and the opportunity to become an officer after I graduated from the University of San Francisco (I attended in my spare time), I left the Air Force in 1987. I LOVED my job. I loved teaching and I loved the intelligence field. My friends were stunned that I was leaving, clueless as to why I would just quit. They were actually quite angry with me, thinking I was crazy. If only they knew I was gay. If only being gay wasn’t a reason to have to quit. What a waste. What a tragedy. What a crime.
Other people should not have to go through what I did. Those who want to serve should be able to do so. Now even the people serving in today’s military agree with that. Below is a letter from the Human Rights Campaign with information on what you can and I hope will do as quickly as possible to bring an end to Don’t Ask Don’t Tell!
From the Human Rights Campaign:
As of this afternoon, there is absolutely no excuse to delay the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell.” Now it’s time to act. The Department of Defense has released its landmark study, 9 months in the making. It came to the same conclusion as numerous experts’ reports and 25 other countries. They all agree on one simple, inescapable truth: Lesbians and gays should serve openly in the U.S. military.
My fellow troops have spoken. Generals have spoken. Think tanks have spoken. The American people have spoken. From this point forward, any delay is nothing more than discrimination and partisan politics. It needs to end.The Senate is holding critical hearings this week and won’t be in session long – so we must act now.
I was the first American wounded in Iraq. I lost my leg. I almost lost my life. When I returned home, I came out – and spoke out against a policy that forced me to hide who I was. I’ve talked to elected officials on both sides of the debate. They all need to hear from us today. The ones with the courage to fight for equal rights still need to hear that voters want them to make it a priority. And the ones who have supported discrimination can still be convinced by the facts highlighted in this new report. I’ve seen it happen.
The evidence is on our side. “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” has always been wrong. But now, it’s not just me or you saying it – it’s the Pentagon’s own study. We’re on the brink of ending injustice – but we all must stand together, right now.
Let’s make this happen – for my brothers and sisters in arms who put themselves on the line to defend us, and for the good of this nation we all love.
In solidarity,
![]()
Eric Alva
Retired Marine Staff Sergeant
P.S. If you have a minute, we need you to make two quick calls. Call (202) 224-3121 right now, ask to be connected to your senators’ offices, and tell them to repeal “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” before they leave for the holidays. Be sure to make two calls, one for each senator in your state. Thenreport your calls. Thank you!




What a heartbreaking, beautifully written story Craig. It moved me. Thank you for sharing it with us.
Brilliantly stated, Craig. Loved the Human Rights Campaign references for ACTION steps too. I’m now up here in patriotic central with my own veteran USN/Ret Capt dad (akin to USAF Col) who surprised me by sounding off in “one world unity” over Thanksgiving shared by a global crew (generations, sexualities, languages, like a mini-UN!) so this is particularly relevant. I will share with others and link to it on SY too…Thank you for your courage and conviction to communicate such a personal slice of your life.