<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
		>
<channel>
	<title>Comments on: Am I A Rebel Yet? Chris Hedges Wouldn&#8217;t Think So.</title>
	<atom:link href="http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/</link>
	<description>A Voice for Tikkun Olam (healing the world)</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Thu, 09 Feb 2012 13:04:30 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>1</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1</generator>
	<item>
		<title>By: Roberto Stensrud</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-12698</link>
		<dc:creator>Roberto Stensrud</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 10 Jul 2010 10:15:00 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-12698</guid>
		<description>Hello there. Exceptional job. Used to do hope this specific. This can be a superb account. Cheers!</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hello there. Exceptional job. Used to do hope this specific. This can be a superb account. Cheers!</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Bruces Point</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7211</link>
		<dc:creator>Bruces Point</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 14 Mar 2010 05:57:08 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7211</guid>
		<description>The Evangelical&#039;s ARE Serious, Take them that way. Nowhere Near All, are totally wrapped into NOW, but the One&#039;s that are, ARE DEAD SERIOUS, You ignore at Your Peril. 
I have Faith&amp;Hope, that the Koolade Hasn&#039;t been mixed yet, but am Really trying to take it&#039;s Pulse, and See if we can get it working as Intended. MY spiritual outlook will be fairly Obvious from This Letter, So I&#039;m biased, can&#039;t Help it. Niether can They. Don&#039;t Blow&#039;em Off. They TRY to live to Their Lights. Smart People in General, though as always, in Everything, the Media, Only shows the Clowns. The True to the Message One&#039;s, Are living the Life they Believe and KNOW. Talk WITH them, not AT them. I think you&#039;ll find some reasonable people there, among the &#039;DryDrunks&quot;, who make the Noise. Talk Gently, Volume goes up, Understanding goes Down. We REALLY Don&#039;t want that. Critiques Always Welcome.
BP.

My letter of explanation and intent/meaning.

**NOT a must read article**

  the Rest is Mine, please read.

Actually, a little balanced, well written, article, for an &quot;Atheist&quot;. Comments section IS a good read, Spiritual folk more than hold their own. Thinking about getting in touch with one of them, a Reverend. &quot;Sounds&quot; Canadian, well spoken/honest/open.
Threw My penny-for-your-thought in. Makes ME Feel better.

&quot;Atheist&quot;, Suffer from an Impoverished Imagination, I Pity them that... Robbed, they were. And &#039;most&#039; of the Noisy Ones, are Just as Incapable of Abstract Thought, as the REALLY Stupid, Other &quot;Fundies&quot; of ALL Stripes are. Haters. NOT my problem.
Lump&#039;em all together.
 My sin, I&#039;m human too.

I AM NOT An ATHEIST!

&quot;Agnostic&quot; Ah, now There, is an interesting word. Human, Humble enough to Admit, that they don&#039;t know the &quot;Answer&quot;, Smart enough, to Know that Something is up, So there Must be AN Answer. Usually balanced enough to explore without obsessing. Looking by their Own &quot;lights&quot;, Not Led by the Nose by some bureaucrat with his hand out. a seekers journey.

  Any Intelligent Soul can take a REALLY Good Look at Nature, and See Humor There.
 Humor takes Intelligence, Ergo there IS Intelligence in the Universe.
  Any Observant Person, can See the Connections in Life, Ergo it is NOT a &quot;Random&quot; Universe.
Simplest one that fit&#039;s. Occam&#039;s Razor, I believe its called. It Really IS a small world, travel&amp;talk, You&#039;ll find out.

 Theories&amp;&quot;Facts&quot;, funny things, they ARE changeable. Most of the One&#039;s WE were taught in school have been superseded, and Obsoleted. The ONLY Certain Thing in the Universe is CHANGE.

I am Not an agnostic, drilled down too tight from the start. Not my Choice. Never had a Chance.

I was Raised, to be Active in the &quot;Church&quot;, Grandpa Style, Steered&amp;Groomed, to further the Gospel, Any way I could possibly. People had &quot;Plans&quot; for me. My family knows what happens when Somebody Tells Me I &#039;Have&quot; to do something. NOT the way to Motivate me.

I started &quot;abstracting&quot; &quot;thought&quot; a Bit before most, my curse, my blessing...

While most of you played &#039;little league&#039; and &#039;House&#039;, I read the Bible through, 3 times. Ask my family what that means.

I have been Looking Forward with Joy to meeting my Maker Ever Since. QuestionsQuestionQuestions!!!
Sometimes in more of a hurry than not, sometimes too much so.  I Still Am Looking Forward Even More Fondly NOW. Will Be WELCOME.
Lizette think&#039;s a little Too fondly, too welcome.

I read my way through Grandpa&amp;Grandma&#039;s Library, the Church Library, the School&#039;s Library&#039;s, the Town&#039;s Library, and was Started on the County&#039;s Library&#039;s. Pretty much had finished what was available of interest there by the time I was in High School.
Kept Going... Taken advantage of every chance to Learn that I could, as possible. When I Stop Learning, I&#039;m dead&amp;done.

I LOVE to Read!!! I LOVE to Learn!!!  Thinking&amp;Imagineering is Pretty Fun Too!=8^D
My Fondest Wish Always has been Time to Read Everything I wanted too, and More &quot;Light&quot; to go with it. Everything Else, is a Hobby.

 It IS a Fascinating&amp;WONDERFUL Universe. And Fun to Share. Wonderful &quot;Things&quot; are happening All the Time. Don&#039; get much Press.
ALL the &quot;Answers&quot; are already there.
 FUD,(Fear, Uncertainy and Doubt), the Manipulators Friend, is What is Fed too People these Day&#039;s. As Always, Truly looking at &quot;history&quot;, Fear ALWAYS motivates or Freezes, separates the Sheep from the Wolves that way. For the Feast.

Easier to pull the Con that way.

I Am totally on board with Jesus&#039;s Message, near as I can make them out and Understand. Would Love to read Direct Aramaic.
I do have some perspective on Who he was aiming&amp;shaping it at...

Have a little debate with him about the turn the other cheek thing. Nice idea, Lived it, Practiced it. Got to where I can REALLY take a punch!!!
NEVER had Anyone put out my lights! Tough Skull! Took a Moose at 57 mph. Didn&#039;t knock me out. Did lizette, unfortunately.
Was great Training for working with Head-Injured patients too.
However I DO Dislike to Reward Bad Behaviour, And Bully&#039;s get too much enjoyment out of causing Others Pain.
Will NOT put up with it Anymore. That goes for Bullying in ANY Form, from ANY one. ESPECIALLY Institutions!!!

I have Always Studied the Mystic&#039;s, Who have &quot;Direct&quot; Experience with God. Go to the Source. Grandpa taught me that.

I have Always studied the Religions, MAN&#039;s creation, Inspired by God. Mostly turned by man, to Control Society, NOT Nurture it.

I have Always studied the Church&#039;s, Again, Man&#039;s creation, Mostly Imperfect, Some Intending to Nuture Human Soul&#039;s, some throw  Nurturing the body in there, Actively, Not Just Talk. Some are Run by ConMen, Some by Saints, Some by MadMen. Some out of Sheer Agape. Like Those. Like the One&#039;s who Build&amp;Contribute to Community. Don&#039;t Like the One&#039;s Run on FUD, for CONTROL.
Detest Those.
Again, My sin, I&#039;m human.
In General, a Good Thing, That sometimes goes Terribly Wrong. Just like Most Human Endeavours.
I served in the Coast Guard, with Congressman Leo Ryan&#039;s Son. It&#039;s a very small world.

I have Seen &quot;Church&#039;s&amp;Religion&#039;s do Terrible Things. Man&#039;s work, Not God&#039;s. Read History, or these days just All the &quot;News&quot;.

I saw a sign, When the Cheerleading for Iraq was Loudest, in front of my Family&#039;s church, bout one of Imperial&#039;s contributions to the Slaughter.
 Said, &quot;Marcus ******, GODS WARRIOR&quot;
I felt like burning it, and the church Down.
Obscenity! FALSE Witness.
The &quot;Church&quot; had been USED to Propagate Propaganda!
Wasn&#039;t, Isn&#039;t, &quot;God&#039;s&quot; War!  All George and Friends. For Oil, Resources, CONTROL, of Other Peoples Land&#039;s.
 And keeping that Merican Military-Industrial complex Primed&amp;Rich.

That&#039;s &quot;God&#039;s&quot; Work? Methinks you misread the book.

 Mom,(E.J.) had the Best take on it I Ever Heard. She was a Wise Woman.

When I Expressed my offence of Hypocrisy of People claiming to be &quot;Godly&quot; at a young age, She Explained to me, That
 &quot;Church&#039;s&quot; were Hospitals for Sinners, Not Sanctuary&#039;s for Saint&#039;s... Best Analogy I have Heard Yet! And VERY Correct.

The more Extreme they are, the &quot;Sicker&quot; they are. Smart Lady.

So. My &quot;Place of Worship&quot; is Out in Nature, Alone with Open&amp;Receiving Mind. I Try Really Hard, to be humble, life helps to keep me that way! I Share, the Wonder, with Others as I can. I Try to ACT, in my life, asking WWJD, WWGPD, and WWMD, My Leading Lights, Filter through That, what my Heart tells me, check head, act accordingly. Accept the Responsibility for MY Actions. Trying NOT to miss the mark.

And You Know What? Grandpa is Right With Me.

&quot;Evangelism&quot; bothers Me. Feel a Human, and a Religion, should live by Example, Not Talking someone else out of Their World Picture and Replacing it with Their Own. Rude.

The &quot;Face&quot; that Our Religion is SHOWING, Most Loudly, in Present Times, in the USA, is UGLY! HUBRIS. False Witness. Greed. TOTAL lack of Tolerance. Some Sick Sinners!!! Take a &quot;Gut&quot; check, and talk to some colleagues ELSEWHERE in the World.

Praying for Control? Greed
Praying for Judges to DIE.  Now THAT I can relate to at the Moment. But NOT Act. But I Know what that is.
Praying Others Harm? Blasphemy. Serious Stuff.

Any Good Witch, can tell you Saying Things Three Times Constitutes a Spell, if directed at something. the Jews Agree.
That is Where they are Dabbling, in that &quot;Prayer Warrior&quot; Bunch. Are Ya&#039;ll with&#039;em? Hope Not. Why it OFFENDS me so much.

A Reality Check. My &quot;Biggest&quot; fear, has Always been to NOT Die with My Eyes Open. Answers Finally!!! Been Waiting Soooo Long.

Had a Chance to test that recently! 3 times.

 Now, Once upon a time, I Studied, and fasted, and Meditated, Got my diet right...
Was Blessed to experience &quot;Satori&quot;, Oneness with the Universe, EveryThing in the Universe, is Going Exactly to Plan, You are Right where you need to be, even got a bit of &quot;Out of Body&quot; Experience, looked down on Myself, wandered a bit, Lovely Experience, and as &#039;Real&quot; as You could get, by My Perception.

 the heart attack? barely hurt when I had it, No where NEAR what my spine does to me, just got short of breath. Little pain in left arm.
When in Hospital...

Each of the 3 Different times, the Heart Stopped.
It was like a switch was thrown.
Here Now.
Not.
Here Now.
Not
Here Now, looking at the doctor as he &quot;Tested&quot; whether I Really needed the Pacemaker&#039;
Not.... Back.
Never Noticed!

Each time. No &quot;Light&quot;, No &quot;Voice&quot;, No Warning.

Very Disappointing! Hoping for Light on that one.

With My Love&amp;My faith,
BP</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Evangelical&#8217;s ARE Serious, Take them that way. Nowhere Near All, are totally wrapped into NOW, but the One&#8217;s that are, ARE DEAD SERIOUS, You ignore at Your Peril.<br />
I have Faith&amp;Hope, that the Koolade Hasn&#8217;t been mixed yet, but am Really trying to take it&#8217;s Pulse, and See if we can get it working as Intended. MY spiritual outlook will be fairly Obvious from This Letter, So I&#8217;m biased, can&#8217;t Help it. Niether can They. Don&#8217;t Blow&#8217;em Off. They TRY to live to Their Lights. Smart People in General, though as always, in Everything, the Media, Only shows the Clowns. The True to the Message One&#8217;s, Are living the Life they Believe and KNOW. Talk WITH them, not AT them. I think you&#8217;ll find some reasonable people there, among the &#8216;DryDrunks&#8221;, who make the Noise. Talk Gently, Volume goes up, Understanding goes Down. We REALLY Don&#8217;t want that. Critiques Always Welcome.<br />
BP.</p>
<p>My letter of explanation and intent/meaning.</p>
<p>**NOT a must read article**</p>
<p>  the Rest is Mine, please read.</p>
<p>Actually, a little balanced, well written, article, for an &#8220;Atheist&#8221;. Comments section IS a good read, Spiritual folk more than hold their own. Thinking about getting in touch with one of them, a Reverend. &#8220;Sounds&#8221; Canadian, well spoken/honest/open.<br />
Threw My penny-for-your-thought in. Makes ME Feel better.</p>
<p>&#8220;Atheist&#8221;, Suffer from an Impoverished Imagination, I Pity them that&#8230; Robbed, they were. And &#8216;most&#8217; of the Noisy Ones, are Just as Incapable of Abstract Thought, as the REALLY Stupid, Other &#8220;Fundies&#8221; of ALL Stripes are. Haters. NOT my problem.<br />
Lump&#8217;em all together.<br />
 My sin, I&#8217;m human too.</p>
<p>I AM NOT An ATHEIST!</p>
<p>&#8220;Agnostic&#8221; Ah, now There, is an interesting word. Human, Humble enough to Admit, that they don&#8217;t know the &#8220;Answer&#8221;, Smart enough, to Know that Something is up, So there Must be AN Answer. Usually balanced enough to explore without obsessing. Looking by their Own &#8220;lights&#8221;, Not Led by the Nose by some bureaucrat with his hand out. a seekers journey.</p>
<p>  Any Intelligent Soul can take a REALLY Good Look at Nature, and See Humor There.<br />
 Humor takes Intelligence, Ergo there IS Intelligence in the Universe.<br />
  Any Observant Person, can See the Connections in Life, Ergo it is NOT a &#8220;Random&#8221; Universe.<br />
Simplest one that fit&#8217;s. Occam&#8217;s Razor, I believe its called. It Really IS a small world, travel&amp;talk, You&#8217;ll find out.</p>
<p> Theories&amp;&#8221;Facts&#8221;, funny things, they ARE changeable. Most of the One&#8217;s WE were taught in school have been superseded, and Obsoleted. The ONLY Certain Thing in the Universe is CHANGE.</p>
<p>I am Not an agnostic, drilled down too tight from the start. Not my Choice. Never had a Chance.</p>
<p>I was Raised, to be Active in the &#8220;Church&#8221;, Grandpa Style, Steered&amp;Groomed, to further the Gospel, Any way I could possibly. People had &#8220;Plans&#8221; for me. My family knows what happens when Somebody Tells Me I &#8216;Have&#8221; to do something. NOT the way to Motivate me.</p>
<p>I started &#8220;abstracting&#8221; &#8220;thought&#8221; a Bit before most, my curse, my blessing&#8230;</p>
<p>While most of you played &#8216;little league&#8217; and &#8216;House&#8217;, I read the Bible through, 3 times. Ask my family what that means.</p>
<p>I have been Looking Forward with Joy to meeting my Maker Ever Since. QuestionsQuestionQuestions!!!<br />
Sometimes in more of a hurry than not, sometimes too much so.  I Still Am Looking Forward Even More Fondly NOW. Will Be WELCOME.<br />
Lizette think&#8217;s a little Too fondly, too welcome.</p>
<p>I read my way through Grandpa&amp;Grandma&#8217;s Library, the Church Library, the School&#8217;s Library&#8217;s, the Town&#8217;s Library, and was Started on the County&#8217;s Library&#8217;s. Pretty much had finished what was available of interest there by the time I was in High School.<br />
Kept Going&#8230; Taken advantage of every chance to Learn that I could, as possible. When I Stop Learning, I&#8217;m dead&amp;done.</p>
<p>I LOVE to Read!!! I LOVE to Learn!!!  Thinking&amp;Imagineering is Pretty Fun Too!=8^D<br />
My Fondest Wish Always has been Time to Read Everything I wanted too, and More &#8220;Light&#8221; to go with it. Everything Else, is a Hobby.</p>
<p> It IS a Fascinating&amp;WONDERFUL Universe. And Fun to Share. Wonderful &#8220;Things&#8221; are happening All the Time. Don&#8217; get much Press.<br />
ALL the &#8220;Answers&#8221; are already there.<br />
 FUD,(Fear, Uncertainy and Doubt), the Manipulators Friend, is What is Fed too People these Day&#8217;s. As Always, Truly looking at &#8220;history&#8221;, Fear ALWAYS motivates or Freezes, separates the Sheep from the Wolves that way. For the Feast.</p>
<p>Easier to pull the Con that way.</p>
<p>I Am totally on board with Jesus&#8217;s Message, near as I can make them out and Understand. Would Love to read Direct Aramaic.<br />
I do have some perspective on Who he was aiming&amp;shaping it at&#8230;</p>
<p>Have a little debate with him about the turn the other cheek thing. Nice idea, Lived it, Practiced it. Got to where I can REALLY take a punch!!!<br />
NEVER had Anyone put out my lights! Tough Skull! Took a Moose at 57 mph. Didn&#8217;t knock me out. Did lizette, unfortunately.<br />
Was great Training for working with Head-Injured patients too.<br />
However I DO Dislike to Reward Bad Behaviour, And Bully&#8217;s get too much enjoyment out of causing Others Pain.<br />
Will NOT put up with it Anymore. That goes for Bullying in ANY Form, from ANY one. ESPECIALLY Institutions!!!</p>
<p>I have Always Studied the Mystic&#8217;s, Who have &#8220;Direct&#8221; Experience with God. Go to the Source. Grandpa taught me that.</p>
<p>I have Always studied the Religions, MAN&#8217;s creation, Inspired by God. Mostly turned by man, to Control Society, NOT Nurture it.</p>
<p>I have Always studied the Church&#8217;s, Again, Man&#8217;s creation, Mostly Imperfect, Some Intending to Nuture Human Soul&#8217;s, some throw  Nurturing the body in there, Actively, Not Just Talk. Some are Run by ConMen, Some by Saints, Some by MadMen. Some out of Sheer Agape. Like Those. Like the One&#8217;s who Build&amp;Contribute to Community. Don&#8217;t Like the One&#8217;s Run on FUD, for CONTROL.<br />
Detest Those.<br />
Again, My sin, I&#8217;m human.<br />
In General, a Good Thing, That sometimes goes Terribly Wrong. Just like Most Human Endeavours.<br />
I served in the Coast Guard, with Congressman Leo Ryan&#8217;s Son. It&#8217;s a very small world.</p>
<p>I have Seen &#8220;Church&#8217;s&amp;Religion&#8217;s do Terrible Things. Man&#8217;s work, Not God&#8217;s. Read History, or these days just All the &#8220;News&#8221;.</p>
<p>I saw a sign, When the Cheerleading for Iraq was Loudest, in front of my Family&#8217;s church, bout one of Imperial&#8217;s contributions to the Slaughter.<br />
 Said, &#8220;Marcus ******, GODS WARRIOR&#8221;<br />
I felt like burning it, and the church Down.<br />
Obscenity! FALSE Witness.<br />
The &#8220;Church&#8221; had been USED to Propagate Propaganda!<br />
Wasn&#8217;t, Isn&#8217;t, &#8220;God&#8217;s&#8221; War!  All George and Friends. For Oil, Resources, CONTROL, of Other Peoples Land&#8217;s.<br />
 And keeping that Merican Military-Industrial complex Primed&amp;Rich.</p>
<p>That&#8217;s &#8220;God&#8217;s&#8221; Work? Methinks you misread the book.</p>
<p> Mom,(E.J.) had the Best take on it I Ever Heard. She was a Wise Woman.</p>
<p>When I Expressed my offence of Hypocrisy of People claiming to be &#8220;Godly&#8221; at a young age, She Explained to me, That<br />
 &#8220;Church&#8217;s&#8221; were Hospitals for Sinners, Not Sanctuary&#8217;s for Saint&#8217;s&#8230; Best Analogy I have Heard Yet! And VERY Correct.</p>
<p>The more Extreme they are, the &#8220;Sicker&#8221; they are. Smart Lady.</p>
<p>So. My &#8220;Place of Worship&#8221; is Out in Nature, Alone with Open&amp;Receiving Mind. I Try Really Hard, to be humble, life helps to keep me that way! I Share, the Wonder, with Others as I can. I Try to ACT, in my life, asking WWJD, WWGPD, and WWMD, My Leading Lights, Filter through That, what my Heart tells me, check head, act accordingly. Accept the Responsibility for MY Actions. Trying NOT to miss the mark.</p>
<p>And You Know What? Grandpa is Right With Me.</p>
<p>&#8220;Evangelism&#8221; bothers Me. Feel a Human, and a Religion, should live by Example, Not Talking someone else out of Their World Picture and Replacing it with Their Own. Rude.</p>
<p>The &#8220;Face&#8221; that Our Religion is SHOWING, Most Loudly, in Present Times, in the USA, is UGLY! HUBRIS. False Witness. Greed. TOTAL lack of Tolerance. Some Sick Sinners!!! Take a &#8220;Gut&#8221; check, and talk to some colleagues ELSEWHERE in the World.</p>
<p>Praying for Control? Greed<br />
Praying for Judges to DIE.  Now THAT I can relate to at the Moment. But NOT Act. But I Know what that is.<br />
Praying Others Harm? Blasphemy. Serious Stuff.</p>
<p>Any Good Witch, can tell you Saying Things Three Times Constitutes a Spell, if directed at something. the Jews Agree.<br />
That is Where they are Dabbling, in that &#8220;Prayer Warrior&#8221; Bunch. Are Ya&#8217;ll with&#8217;em? Hope Not. Why it OFFENDS me so much.</p>
<p>A Reality Check. My &#8220;Biggest&#8221; fear, has Always been to NOT Die with My Eyes Open. Answers Finally!!! Been Waiting Soooo Long.</p>
<p>Had a Chance to test that recently! 3 times.</p>
<p> Now, Once upon a time, I Studied, and fasted, and Meditated, Got my diet right&#8230;<br />
Was Blessed to experience &#8220;Satori&#8221;, Oneness with the Universe, EveryThing in the Universe, is Going Exactly to Plan, You are Right where you need to be, even got a bit of &#8220;Out of Body&#8221; Experience, looked down on Myself, wandered a bit, Lovely Experience, and as &#8216;Real&#8221; as You could get, by My Perception.</p>
<p> the heart attack? barely hurt when I had it, No where NEAR what my spine does to me, just got short of breath. Little pain in left arm.<br />
When in Hospital&#8230;</p>
<p>Each of the 3 Different times, the Heart Stopped.<br />
It was like a switch was thrown.<br />
Here Now.<br />
Not.<br />
Here Now.<br />
Not<br />
Here Now, looking at the doctor as he &#8220;Tested&#8221; whether I Really needed the Pacemaker&#8217;<br />
Not&#8230;. Back.<br />
Never Noticed!</p>
<p>Each time. No &#8220;Light&#8221;, No &#8220;Voice&#8221;, No Warning.</p>
<p>Very Disappointing! Hoping for Light on that one.</p>
<p>With My Love&amp;My faith,<br />
BP</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Bruces Point</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7210</link>
		<dc:creator>Bruces Point</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 14 Mar 2010 05:17:10 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7210</guid>
		<description>What ORIGINALLY got me Off of my Butt, was a Story bout the &#039;Christian&#039; Dominionist Types&#039;s that Sarah Palin &quot;pals around&quot; with, wanting a Christian Fascist State, To &quot;Give&quot; to Jesus for his &quot;ComingHome&quot; Party, Where they all meet&amp;greet the &quot;Man&quot;, and get a Personal Autograph for their Bible... EGO! Not what I was raised to Believe in. Told them so in some rather steamed word&#039;s. Not &#039;cool&#039; with Burning Witches OR Book&#039;s. Not on My Watch.  BP

&quot;Here it tis, the MindMine that set me off! and my action. Read it,
INTERESTING comments

Hello Family, apologize for passing my Outrage along, But Y&#039;all CAN Do
Something bout this...

    Putting the X, in Xtianity, These People Have NOTHING to do with
Jesus, Other than Defaming his name... What&#039;s the Deal, are Your
Churches pushing this FUD, (Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt, the
Rebullican/Fascist Best Tool), Or Countering it???? These People are
PRAYING Others harm!!! They WILL Burn &quot;Witches&quot; if allowed the Oxygen,
(Media+Fools&amp;Bigots+ those who Profit by it), to grow. Where is Jesus?
 NOT With These Idiots. But then the Only &quot;Houses of God&quot; Making Noise
and Getting Oxygen in the Media are the One&#039;s PUSHING it!!! I am
hearing tones of &quot;subhuman&quot;, and ANY Student of History KNOWS where
that leads.
    Stand Up to these Impostors, and Get Religion Working for the
Well Being of Earth and the Residents of it... , ALL of them, It IS
Your Children&#039;s, and Our ONLY Home. If You are in a RUSH to Join
Jesus, DO IT! Don&#039;t try to drag the Rest of the World into Your
Dreams&amp;Wishes, By Force! A Better Alternative is to Work to Get All
Humans the Chance of Their Dreams Too, Help make the World a Better
Place, And THEN Share Jesus&#039;s Message GENTLY, With Some REAL Win/Win
DEED&#039;s Behind You , Not Using the Message as a Club, backed by a
Physical one. That is EVIL. But then Our &quot;Representative Government&quot;
has been Doing a bit of that, without the &quot;Church&quot; making a peep,
Evidently bureaucrats of God, are not speaking with God. Or Even
listening. Any of You... ??? Love to hear your answer.
     Prove me Wrong, Please.
 BP

http://www.alternet.org/story/145796/heads_up:_prayer_warriors_and_sarah_palin_are_organizing_spiritual_warfare_to_take_over_america_?page=1</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What ORIGINALLY got me Off of my Butt, was a Story bout the &#8216;Christian&#8217; Dominionist Types&#8217;s that Sarah Palin &#8220;pals around&#8221; with, wanting a Christian Fascist State, To &#8220;Give&#8221; to Jesus for his &#8220;ComingHome&#8221; Party, Where they all meet&amp;greet the &#8220;Man&#8221;, and get a Personal Autograph for their Bible&#8230; EGO! Not what I was raised to Believe in. Told them so in some rather steamed word&#8217;s. Not &#8216;cool&#8217; with Burning Witches OR Book&#8217;s. Not on My Watch.  BP</p>
<p>&#8220;Here it tis, the MindMine that set me off! and my action. Read it,<br />
INTERESTING comments</p>
<p>Hello Family, apologize for passing my Outrage along, But Y&#8217;all CAN Do<br />
Something bout this&#8230;</p>
<p>    Putting the X, in Xtianity, These People Have NOTHING to do with<br />
Jesus, Other than Defaming his name&#8230; What&#8217;s the Deal, are Your<br />
Churches pushing this FUD, (Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt, the<br />
Rebullican/Fascist Best Tool), Or Countering it???? These People are<br />
PRAYING Others harm!!! They WILL Burn &#8220;Witches&#8221; if allowed the Oxygen,<br />
(Media+Fools&amp;Bigots+ those who Profit by it), to grow. Where is Jesus?<br />
 NOT With These Idiots. But then the Only &#8220;Houses of God&#8221; Making Noise<br />
and Getting Oxygen in the Media are the One&#8217;s PUSHING it!!! I am<br />
hearing tones of &#8220;subhuman&#8221;, and ANY Student of History KNOWS where<br />
that leads.<br />
    Stand Up to these Impostors, and Get Religion Working for the<br />
Well Being of Earth and the Residents of it&#8230; , ALL of them, It IS<br />
Your Children&#8217;s, and Our ONLY Home. If You are in a RUSH to Join<br />
Jesus, DO IT! Don&#8217;t try to drag the Rest of the World into Your<br />
Dreams&amp;Wishes, By Force! A Better Alternative is to Work to Get All<br />
Humans the Chance of Their Dreams Too, Help make the World a Better<br />
Place, And THEN Share Jesus&#8217;s Message GENTLY, With Some REAL Win/Win<br />
DEED&#8217;s Behind You , Not Using the Message as a Club, backed by a<br />
Physical one. That is EVIL. But then Our &#8220;Representative Government&#8221;<br />
has been Doing a bit of that, without the &#8220;Church&#8221; making a peep,<br />
Evidently bureaucrats of God, are not speaking with God. Or Even<br />
listening. Any of You&#8230; ??? Love to hear your answer.<br />
     Prove me Wrong, Please.<br />
 BP</p>
<p><a href="http://www.alternet.org/story/145796/heads_up:_prayer_warriors_and_sarah_palin_are_organizing_spiritual_warfare_to_take_over_america_?page=1" rel="nofollow">http://www.alternet.org/story/145796/heads_up:_prayer_warriors_and_sarah_palin_are_organizing_spiritual_warfare_to_take_over_america_?page=1</a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Bruces Point</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7207</link>
		<dc:creator>Bruces Point</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 14 Mar 2010 04:51:13 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7207</guid>
		<description>I am in the midst of an effort, to get my VERY Solid, in Depth, Conservative Christian Evangelical family, into a dialog about the shape things are taking, and What is Needed for Sanity in the body politic, as it where. Hoping to come up with a dialog, that will be Seen, Passed round, and Hopefully generate some Bridges in Family&#039;s, to start Talking this stuff out, Without having to call 911. We have a LOT of depth to the family, for Most part, here from the start of this whole Idea, the USA. Have &quot;Greats&quot; participating All the way through, some notably, at least 1 infamously, by My light&#039;s. One I would nominate for Sainthood, and No, it&#039;s Not Mom. Further back, though she get&#039;s an honorable mention, appreciate her Allowing all of us to Survive adolescence. Won&#039;t get thru to all, but should help a slice, doing what I can. Want to share the results of this when/if Rolling good. Still waiting for the Pastor&#039;s to Chime in, Will be sending them here for this Response.  The Excerpt is My response&amp;recomendation to C. Hedges Article.
Bit bout me.
   I am an Expat, left  to marry a Wonderful Canadian, when We were tossing where to settle, &quot;Merica&quot; re-elected Bush. Guess where I live and Happily Own Land now! NOT moving back, unless Sanity takes&amp;hold&#039;s, probably not then. Soured, would have ended up making some Really futile Gesture if I&#039;d stayed. People Get the Government They Dis-serve... 
 But I&#039;ll Visit! Maybe.
Has Felt like a Police State down there for awhile now, Wife, from England Originally, Refuses to go because of that. But then Her parent&#039;s, Polish&amp;English, Dealt firsthand with the Nazi&#039;s, Father Lost most his Family. They Remember, Idiot&#039;s here Don&#039;t. Heard a Real intuitive Kid say, &quot; it Smells like Death Down Here&quot;, My Wife agrees.
Anyhow, wordy it may be, but here&#039;s some Excerpt&#039;s, Critique Welcome:

&quot;This, is a beautiful piece of work, Just out, that Lay&#039;s it Right
Down, it is Your Duty, as a Citizen, and a Human, to READ THIS. Share
This, Say&#039;s it in Clear, Unambiguous terms. Please do read it,
Particularly the part analyzing Rebels and Why they DO. It Is already
started. Remember, Most of the USA Likes to think of themselves as
Rebels. NOW the rubber meets the road.

   STUPID is gonna breakout Everywhere. Please Don&#039;t join in on the
Stupid part, Your Children Will NEVER forgive YOU! My children already
have, for NOT bringing them Into this Mess, without getting Off My
Ass, to make it Right. Time IS short to steer Anything. Soon, Not A
Chance, do YOU want to be Accountable for THAT?
    I Would Like to hear from the Folks who aspired to, Thought
about, Had, or Do have, a Flock, Do I Have to call you by Name? YOU
have a Responsibility! if your &quot;Belief&quot; is Strong, Your &quot;Faith&quot; Ought
to give you solid ground to stand on. Meet Me. Preferably Halfway, but
I&#039;ll take Whatever You have the Courage to talk about. As You Know,
some things that Work at a Personal level, Don&#039;t Work at a Societal
level. We Live in a DEMOCRACY. It&#039;s NOT working Well at the Moment, it
WILL pass, with some tuning, Without... I Think Not. You Think You
Have a BETTER Alternative, Impress Me. Right NOW, all that IS showing
is a buncha whiners, getting Ready to take their Marbles Home, Don&#039;t
think that THAT is going to Impress Anyone. Much less the One we All
want to.

Still Missing the Mark
BP</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am in the midst of an effort, to get my VERY Solid, in Depth, Conservative Christian Evangelical family, into a dialog about the shape things are taking, and What is Needed for Sanity in the body politic, as it where. Hoping to come up with a dialog, that will be Seen, Passed round, and Hopefully generate some Bridges in Family&#8217;s, to start Talking this stuff out, Without having to call 911. We have a LOT of depth to the family, for Most part, here from the start of this whole Idea, the USA. Have &#8220;Greats&#8221; participating All the way through, some notably, at least 1 infamously, by My light&#8217;s. One I would nominate for Sainthood, and No, it&#8217;s Not Mom. Further back, though she get&#8217;s an honorable mention, appreciate her Allowing all of us to Survive adolescence. Won&#8217;t get thru to all, but should help a slice, doing what I can. Want to share the results of this when/if Rolling good. Still waiting for the Pastor&#8217;s to Chime in, Will be sending them here for this Response.  The Excerpt is My response&amp;recomendation to C. Hedges Article.<br />
Bit bout me.<br />
   I am an Expat, left  to marry a Wonderful Canadian, when We were tossing where to settle, &#8220;Merica&#8221; re-elected Bush. Guess where I live and Happily Own Land now! NOT moving back, unless Sanity takes&amp;hold&#8217;s, probably not then. Soured, would have ended up making some Really futile Gesture if I&#8217;d stayed. People Get the Government They Dis-serve&#8230;<br />
 But I&#8217;ll Visit! Maybe.<br />
Has Felt like a Police State down there for awhile now, Wife, from England Originally, Refuses to go because of that. But then Her parent&#8217;s, Polish&amp;English, Dealt firsthand with the Nazi&#8217;s, Father Lost most his Family. They Remember, Idiot&#8217;s here Don&#8217;t. Heard a Real intuitive Kid say, &#8221; it Smells like Death Down Here&#8221;, My Wife agrees.<br />
Anyhow, wordy it may be, but here&#8217;s some Excerpt&#8217;s, Critique Welcome:</p>
<p>&#8220;This, is a beautiful piece of work, Just out, that Lay&#8217;s it Right<br />
Down, it is Your Duty, as a Citizen, and a Human, to READ THIS. Share<br />
This, Say&#8217;s it in Clear, Unambiguous terms. Please do read it,<br />
Particularly the part analyzing Rebels and Why they DO. It Is already<br />
started. Remember, Most of the USA Likes to think of themselves as<br />
Rebels. NOW the rubber meets the road.</p>
<p>   STUPID is gonna breakout Everywhere. Please Don&#8217;t join in on the<br />
Stupid part, Your Children Will NEVER forgive YOU! My children already<br />
have, for NOT bringing them Into this Mess, without getting Off My<br />
Ass, to make it Right. Time IS short to steer Anything. Soon, Not A<br />
Chance, do YOU want to be Accountable for THAT?<br />
    I Would Like to hear from the Folks who aspired to, Thought<br />
about, Had, or Do have, a Flock, Do I Have to call you by Name? YOU<br />
have a Responsibility! if your &#8220;Belief&#8221; is Strong, Your &#8220;Faith&#8221; Ought<br />
to give you solid ground to stand on. Meet Me. Preferably Halfway, but<br />
I&#8217;ll take Whatever You have the Courage to talk about. As You Know,<br />
some things that Work at a Personal level, Don&#8217;t Work at a Societal<br />
level. We Live in a DEMOCRACY. It&#8217;s NOT working Well at the Moment, it<br />
WILL pass, with some tuning, Without&#8230; I Think Not. You Think You<br />
Have a BETTER Alternative, Impress Me. Right NOW, all that IS showing<br />
is a buncha whiners, getting Ready to take their Marbles Home, Don&#8217;t<br />
think that THAT is going to Impress Anyone. Much less the One we All<br />
want to.</p>
<p>Still Missing the Mark<br />
BP</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: babeuf</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7193</link>
		<dc:creator>babeuf</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sun, 14 Mar 2010 01:40:49 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7193</guid>
		<description>Dave, just wondering--why so much attention in Tikkun to Hedges (I&#039;m guessing becuase he has a religious bent?) He seems a competent, if somewhat mach, journalist. But as a political commentator, he seems to be an unbearable blowhard, with provocateurish (or maybe just testosterone fueled) tendencies. Doesn;t see worth the attention.</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dave, just wondering&#8211;why so much attention in Tikkun to Hedges (I&#8217;m guessing becuase he has a religious bent?) He seems a competent, if somewhat mach, journalist. But as a political commentator, he seems to be an unbearable blowhard, with provocateurish (or maybe just testosterone fueled) tendencies. Doesn;t see worth the attention.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Gwendoline Y. Fortune</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7147</link>
		<dc:creator>Gwendoline Y. Fortune</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 13 Mar 2010 01:07:55 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7147</guid>
		<description>Despite reading the many  thoughtful articles in the daily blog, my favorite activity is reading the varying, multiple responses to the initial post, and to one another. At the risk of seeming insipid, even Pollannish--which I definitely am not--what I discern in the exchanges are sincere, informed attitudes and efforts to honestly express the self to the issue. As an interdisciplinary social scientist, born under Libra, although my Buddhist teacher says I&#039;m just pretending to be balanced, being balanced is my consciously chosen attitude. Very difficult to do. I fseel the modicum of validity in differing responses. I try to discern the background of experience--even genetic and environmental that forms our reaction and response. I wish this could be a major part of everyone&#039;s thinking,  feeling and responding--&quot;Know thyself.&quot; We are each expressing our formed selves.  I think I am more in the &quot;camp&quot; of Marcos. I  can be wrong. So, another cliche, &quot;different strokes for differing folk&quot;--if we know why and how we, actually, differ. I am convinced--I think--that when enough of us can accept the validity of what seems different we may be able to arrive at cooperative arrangements.</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Despite reading the many  thoughtful articles in the daily blog, my favorite activity is reading the varying, multiple responses to the initial post, and to one another. At the risk of seeming insipid, even Pollannish&#8211;which I definitely am not&#8211;what I discern in the exchanges are sincere, informed attitudes and efforts to honestly express the self to the issue. As an interdisciplinary social scientist, born under Libra, although my Buddhist teacher says I&#8217;m just pretending to be balanced, being balanced is my consciously chosen attitude. Very difficult to do. I fseel the modicum of validity in differing responses. I try to discern the background of experience&#8211;even genetic and environmental that forms our reaction and response. I wish this could be a major part of everyone&#8217;s thinking,  feeling and responding&#8211;&#8221;Know thyself.&#8221; We are each expressing our formed selves.  I think I am more in the &#8220;camp&#8221; of Marcos. I  can be wrong. So, another cliche, &#8220;different strokes for differing folk&#8221;&#8211;if we know why and how we, actually, differ. I am convinced&#8211;I think&#8211;that when enough of us can accept the validity of what seems different we may be able to arrive at cooperative arrangements.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Marco</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7122</link>
		<dc:creator>Marco</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 12 Mar 2010 01:49:59 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7122</guid>
		<description>Mr Belden: I think you make a good point in saying that many people were agreeably surprised that King and Gandhi were as successful as they were. But they were so because they were dealing with 1) in Gandhi&#039;s instance, with a collapsing British empire in the 30&#039;s and 40`s (collapsing under the pressure of anti-colonialism within and without Britain); and 2) in King&#039;s instance, dealing with a less racist and inhumane USA in the 60`s. Before those respective periods, it was too risky to rebel non-violently; massacre was assurred (which probably many pacifists would have welcomed to fulfill their martyr complexes , sort of pacifist Al-Queda types...). In the case of Fascists and Nazis, and Somozas, only armed might could subdue them at any time, in my opinion. But most pacifists feel that even in those latter  instances it was wrong to use force!  And there are many such pacifists in contemporary &quot;peace&quot; movements, the majority I beleive. How can such unrealistic policies be taken seriously by those persons in the mainstream looking for alternatives to their society? How can one not be enraged as a person of the left (which I consider myself to be) by seeing my &quot;colleagues&quot; on the Left recommend such pacifist nonsense? Similarly, how can one not be enraged by a Howard Zinn , who suggests ,in his much-read book on the Left,  &quot;A People&#039;s History of the USA&quot;, that there was a MORAL EQUIVALENCY between the Allies and the Nazis, ie NO Difference between Hitler and Roosevelt  (only some obscure pacifists and anarchists of the time,according to Zinn, were apparently the only islands of sanity in an insane world)? This is a widely held  view on the Left, the dominant one. So I dissociate myself from the Zinns, and Chomskys, and Hermans, and Cockburns and the Jane Fondas who propogate these gross insensitive views..and I do so with justified anger..and if that anger offends &quot;spiritual&quot; people, too bad.

Finally, thanks for the article about Niebuhr.

Marco</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Mr Belden: I think you make a good point in saying that many people were agreeably surprised that King and Gandhi were as successful as they were. But they were so because they were dealing with 1) in Gandhi&#8217;s instance, with a collapsing British empire in the 30&#8242;s and 40`s (collapsing under the pressure of anti-colonialism within and without Britain); and 2) in King&#8217;s instance, dealing with a less racist and inhumane USA in the 60`s. Before those respective periods, it was too risky to rebel non-violently; massacre was assurred (which probably many pacifists would have welcomed to fulfill their martyr complexes , sort of pacifist Al-Queda types&#8230;). In the case of Fascists and Nazis, and Somozas, only armed might could subdue them at any time, in my opinion. But most pacifists feel that even in those latter  instances it was wrong to use force!  And there are many such pacifists in contemporary &#8220;peace&#8221; movements, the majority I beleive. How can such unrealistic policies be taken seriously by those persons in the mainstream looking for alternatives to their society? How can one not be enraged as a person of the left (which I consider myself to be) by seeing my &#8220;colleagues&#8221; on the Left recommend such pacifist nonsense? Similarly, how can one not be enraged by a Howard Zinn , who suggests ,in his much-read book on the Left,  &#8220;A People&#8217;s History of the USA&#8221;, that there was a MORAL EQUIVALENCY between the Allies and the Nazis, ie NO Difference between Hitler and Roosevelt  (only some obscure pacifists and anarchists of the time,according to Zinn, were apparently the only islands of sanity in an insane world)? This is a widely held  view on the Left, the dominant one. So I dissociate myself from the Zinns, and Chomskys, and Hermans, and Cockburns and the Jane Fondas who propogate these gross insensitive views..and I do so with justified anger..and if that anger offends &#8220;spiritual&#8221; people, too bad.</p>
<p>Finally, thanks for the article about Niebuhr.</p>
<p>Marco</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Dave Belden</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7121</link>
		<dc:creator>Dave Belden</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 12 Mar 2010 00:22:53 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7121</guid>
		<description>David, &quot;slightly peevish&quot; may well be right about this post, but I feel like responding to &quot;unnecessarily personal.&quot; I read a lot about what we should do or what an author believes, but this isn&#039;t always linked enough to what they actually do, or what challenges they find in living out their proposals. The personal/political connection is fascinating to me. For each of us it does come down to what decisions we actually make, and I like the way a blog enables that kind of writing. But it isn&#039;t to everyone&#039;s taste. 

Marco, You make some very strong points, and since I am not a pacifist in any absolutist way, nor well schooled in arguing pacifism&#039;s case, I don&#039;t know what I would think about all these specific instances if I took more time to read the books on nonviolence I have on my shelf. You say the moral appeal rarely works, but it feels to me as if we are only in the early stages of developing it as a tool of social change, and that it requires a great deal more social invention to make it work more often. I agree that we never get away from coercion altogether, and often have to choose one type over another; at the same time, not many of those who see the world through a coercion-lens (seeing above all the coercion and power dynamics in every interaction) would have predicted that MLK or Gandhi could have been as successful as they were -- MLK and co. were roundly abused by those who thought him too &quot;weak&quot; as it was. 

As for Niebuhr, you might be interested in this article in Tikkun by Gary Dorrien, which argues that Niebuhr was wrong in his socialist period, when he denounced the system in tones somewhat similar to Chris Hedges today, and wrong later:
&quot;The Social Gospelers told a story about the necessity of gradually democratizing society; Niebuhr told a more dramatic story, that history would either move forward to socialism or move backward to barbarism. There was no third way. Radical socialism, communism, and fascism were supposedly more realistic than the tame progressivism of the social democratic, Social Gospel, and New Deal movements. But the radical alternatives crashed and burned, and afterward Niebuhr retreated to welfare state reformism and the liberal Democratic mainstream.&quot; From http://www.tikkun.org/article.php/jan10_socialism</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>David, &#8220;slightly peevish&#8221; may well be right about this post, but I feel like responding to &#8220;unnecessarily personal.&#8221; I read a lot about what we should do or what an author believes, but this isn&#8217;t always linked enough to what they actually do, or what challenges they find in living out their proposals. The personal/political connection is fascinating to me. For each of us it does come down to what decisions we actually make, and I like the way a blog enables that kind of writing. But it isn&#8217;t to everyone&#8217;s taste. </p>
<p>Marco, You make some very strong points, and since I am not a pacifist in any absolutist way, nor well schooled in arguing pacifism&#8217;s case, I don&#8217;t know what I would think about all these specific instances if I took more time to read the books on nonviolence I have on my shelf. You say the moral appeal rarely works, but it feels to me as if we are only in the early stages of developing it as a tool of social change, and that it requires a great deal more social invention to make it work more often. I agree that we never get away from coercion altogether, and often have to choose one type over another; at the same time, not many of those who see the world through a coercion-lens (seeing above all the coercion and power dynamics in every interaction) would have predicted that MLK or Gandhi could have been as successful as they were &#8212; MLK and co. were roundly abused by those who thought him too &#8220;weak&#8221; as it was. </p>
<p>As for Niebuhr, you might be interested in this article in Tikkun by Gary Dorrien, which argues that Niebuhr was wrong in his socialist period, when he denounced the system in tones somewhat similar to Chris Hedges today, and wrong later:<br />
&#8220;The Social Gospelers told a story about the necessity of gradually democratizing society; Niebuhr told a more dramatic story, that history would either move forward to socialism or move backward to barbarism. There was no third way. Radical socialism, communism, and fascism were supposedly more realistic than the tame progressivism of the social democratic, Social Gospel, and New Deal movements. But the radical alternatives crashed and burned, and afterward Niebuhr retreated to welfare state reformism and the liberal Democratic mainstream.&#8221; From <a href="http://www.tikkun.org/article.php/jan10_socialism" rel="nofollow">http://www.tikkun.org/article.php/jan10_socialism</a></p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: david wolinsky</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7120</link>
		<dc:creator>david wolinsky</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 11 Mar 2010 23:33:41 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7120</guid>
		<description>Can I pretend to channel Lauren&#039;s uncle? There is both desperation and profound truth/ hope in &quot;Anyone not busy being born is busy dying&quot;. Altho&#039; I&#039;m speaking from personal experience as much as reflection, I think Dave&#039;s slightly peevish and uneccesarily first-person response to Hedges is this: When anyone puts us in an apocalyptic story, we squirm like hell :-). And for good reason. When to risk arrest, when to risk worse than arrest etc. etc. are heavy questions for our sacred personal selves. They have less to do with anger and other emotions, I think, than what Havel seems to be accurately reporting above.

Hedges is pulling alarms in what is anyway a rather shaky progressive edifice. (&quot;There&#039;s no there there&quot; sometimes seems like the actual meaning of &quot;peace community,&quot; for example). But alarm bells evoke a fight/flight response, and no one can remain an adrenaline factory for the long run. (Hedges the former war-reporter is actually an expert on that subject).

Me? I&#039;m happy to cling to shreds of community like Tikkun, but need Hedges, Camus, Chomsky to ground (strange as it sounds) my sense of meaning and hope. I also know that what I actually do (if I am still free to choose -- always a nasty little caveat.) will come more from my sense of the individuals involved than anything else. &#039; been wrong before, paid a big price. &#039; hope the country and world can afford such experimentalism in what may indeed be the age of &quot;inverted totalitarianism.&quot; (Seems that Wolinsky is reading Wolin. Maybe I&#039;ll take an existential leap and submit a book review to a certain magazine that certainly doesn&#039;t appreciate my poems.)</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Can I pretend to channel Lauren&#8217;s uncle? There is both desperation and profound truth/ hope in &#8220;Anyone not busy being born is busy dying&#8221;. Altho&#8217; I&#8217;m speaking from personal experience as much as reflection, I think Dave&#8217;s slightly peevish and uneccesarily first-person response to Hedges is this: When anyone puts us in an apocalyptic story, we squirm like hell :-). And for good reason. When to risk arrest, when to risk worse than arrest etc. etc. are heavy questions for our sacred personal selves. They have less to do with anger and other emotions, I think, than what Havel seems to be accurately reporting above.</p>
<p>Hedges is pulling alarms in what is anyway a rather shaky progressive edifice. (&#8220;There&#8217;s no there there&#8221; sometimes seems like the actual meaning of &#8220;peace community,&#8221; for example). But alarm bells evoke a fight/flight response, and no one can remain an adrenaline factory for the long run. (Hedges the former war-reporter is actually an expert on that subject).</p>
<p>Me? I&#8217;m happy to cling to shreds of community like Tikkun, but need Hedges, Camus, Chomsky to ground (strange as it sounds) my sense of meaning and hope. I also know that what I actually do (if I am still free to choose &#8212; always a nasty little caveat.) will come more from my sense of the individuals involved than anything else. &#8216; been wrong before, paid a big price. &#8216; hope the country and world can afford such experimentalism in what may indeed be the age of &#8220;inverted totalitarianism.&#8221; (Seems that Wolinsky is reading Wolin. Maybe I&#8217;ll take an existential leap and submit a book review to a certain magazine that certainly doesn&#8217;t appreciate my poems.)</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Marco</title>
		<link>http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/comment-page-1/#comment-7118</link>
		<dc:creator>Marco</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 11 Mar 2010 23:25:49 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/?p=10962#comment-7118</guid>
		<description>Those responding to my critique of Mr Belden were pretty predictable: hate and retaliation leads to more hate, blah, blah, blah...and we pacifists are the ones who are going to change everything thru our good vibes. Well a just a war against the Nazis lead to now-democratic Germany and Japan; so that pacifist nonsense about hate inevitably leading to hate in an endless cycle is refuted. However, it is true that SOMETIMES a rebellion does not lead to a better government (EX: Khomeini in Iran), but sometimes it does if the rebels have the VIOLENT POWER and half-way decent souls (as F. Roosevelt). But you pacifists equate all violent power with depravity, and you are, of course, &quot;above&quot; all that.

With respect to appealing to the enemy&#039;s moral sense, that rarely works. The only reason King et al. won some major advances is that they got through to liberals who just had to be nudged in the right direction. They, being a majority  in the Sixties ,passed legislation FORCING racists to desegrate in the south. How many racists did King et al. get through to morally? Not many, I would wager. Had liberals not been convinced, the Southern racists would have massacred the Civil Rights people. And then, as in South Africa, the only two options would have been: submit, or take up the gun. In South Africa, Mandela et al took up the gun, which was instrumental in bringing some of those whites to their senses, and paving the way to negotiations. 

And what about this contradiction between King&#039;s pacifism and the fact the Civil Rights movement wanted , understandably , legislation, outlawing segregation and discrimination. If you pass a law, it THREATHENS those who do not submit with retaliation and punishment. Is that pacifist? No. But it is reasonable and just. And, finally, if John and Robert Kennedy had not sent police and troops to defend Civil Rights workers at critical junctures, they would have been massacred (as when they were caught in a church). What difference is that with an anti-racist movement having its own troops defend themselves with guns and fists? You pacifists are full of contradictions, nonsense, and moral sellf-righteousness. Hey, if you want to pitch yourselves in front of an Israeli tank, go ahead, I don&#039;t. 

And , oh yeah, you might want to read the political writings of a famous American Christian theologian, Rheinhold Niebuhr, very influential in the Democratic Party in the last 20 years of his life. He started off as a pacifist and Christian socialist, and ended up as a just-war proponent in the 1930`s, and a humane capitalism advocate a la New Deal.

Marco




Marco</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Those responding to my critique of Mr Belden were pretty predictable: hate and retaliation leads to more hate, blah, blah, blah&#8230;and we pacifists are the ones who are going to change everything thru our good vibes. Well a just a war against the Nazis lead to now-democratic Germany and Japan; so that pacifist nonsense about hate inevitably leading to hate in an endless cycle is refuted. However, it is true that SOMETIMES a rebellion does not lead to a better government (EX: Khomeini in Iran), but sometimes it does if the rebels have the VIOLENT POWER and half-way decent souls (as F. Roosevelt). But you pacifists equate all violent power with depravity, and you are, of course, &#8220;above&#8221; all that.</p>
<p>With respect to appealing to the enemy&#8217;s moral sense, that rarely works. The only reason King et al. won some major advances is that they got through to liberals who just had to be nudged in the right direction. They, being a majority  in the Sixties ,passed legislation FORCING racists to desegrate in the south. How many racists did King et al. get through to morally? Not many, I would wager. Had liberals not been convinced, the Southern racists would have massacred the Civil Rights people. And then, as in South Africa, the only two options would have been: submit, or take up the gun. In South Africa, Mandela et al took up the gun, which was instrumental in bringing some of those whites to their senses, and paving the way to negotiations. </p>
<p>And what about this contradiction between King&#8217;s pacifism and the fact the Civil Rights movement wanted , understandably , legislation, outlawing segregation and discrimination. If you pass a law, it THREATHENS those who do not submit with retaliation and punishment. Is that pacifist? No. But it is reasonable and just. And, finally, if John and Robert Kennedy had not sent police and troops to defend Civil Rights workers at critical junctures, they would have been massacred (as when they were caught in a church). What difference is that with an anti-racist movement having its own troops defend themselves with guns and fists? You pacifists are full of contradictions, nonsense, and moral sellf-righteousness. Hey, if you want to pitch yourselves in front of an Israeli tank, go ahead, I don&#8217;t. </p>
<p>And , oh yeah, you might want to read the political writings of a famous American Christian theologian, Rheinhold Niebuhr, very influential in the Democratic Party in the last 20 years of his life. He started off as a pacifist and Christian socialist, and ended up as a just-war proponent in the 1930`s, and a humane capitalism advocate a la New Deal.</p>
<p>Marco</p>
<p>Marco</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
</channel>
</rss>
<!-- This Quick Cache file was built for (  www.tikkun.org/tikkundaily/2010/03/10/am-i-a-rebel-yet-chris-hedges-wouldnt-think-so/feed/ ) in 0.77033 seconds, on Feb 9th, 2012 at 7:47 pm UTC. -->
<!-- This Quick Cache file will automatically expire ( and be re-built automatically ) on Feb 9th, 2012 at 8:27 pm UTC -->
