“Quest” Mentoring, Not Spiritual Direction
by: Nancy Vedder-Shults on October 30th, 2009 | 6 Comments »
We’ve started a new program named “Quest” at First Unitarian Society (FUS). FUS created Quest in order to help members who want it to develop a deeper commitment to their spiritual journey. Some of the introductory writings about the program describe it as “a journey toward wholeness, holiness, and peace.” It’s a very exciting two-year “pilgrimage,” and I’m blessed to be a part of it as a mentor to two women who are participants.
Today one of my partners contacted me. I’d just finished re-reading a chapter from Parker Palmer‘s A Hidden Wholeness: The Journey Toward An Undivided Life about “Being Along Together,” a good metaphor for my role in this process. And yesterday I had finally bought two chairs for my meditation room, where I hope to meet with my partners –if that’s what they want. So synchonicities are lining up to indicate the “rightness” of this choice.
For several years now, I’ve been considering spiritual direction as a new option in my life, and being asked to become a Quest mentor helped strengthen this interest. Sometimes referred to as spiritual guidance or spiritual friendship, spiritual direction like mentoring takes place in a one-to-one relationship, in which a person who wants to become more attentive to their spiritual life meets regularly with a “spiritual director,” in order to awaken more fully to the presence of spirit and how it moves through their existence. I’m not using “God language” here, because not all UUs are comfortable with it. But what I realized while re-reading Parker Palmer is just how uncomfortable I am with the term “spiritual direction.”
Direction is NOT what I will be providing as a Quest mentor. I will be supporting and nurturing my partners’ spiritual journeys so they will connect with their own inner teachers, their spiritual selves — or what Parker Palmer calls their souls — the true “directors” of their spiritual growth. I will help them integrate their own personal spiritual values into practice, but I certainly won’t be directing anything.
In fact, if I take up “spiritual direction,” I won’t direct anything either. I will co-create a space with my partners where spirit can be present. Palmer gives a good description of the alternate view:
A process in which the pressure of orthodox doctrine, sacred text, and institutional authority is applied to the misshapen soul in order to conform it to the shape dictated by some theology. This approach is rooted in the idea that we are born with souls deformed by sin, and our situation is hopeless until the authorities ["direct"] us properly.
I have great difficulty with the concept of “original sin,” so realizing just where the direction part of “spiritual direction” originated repelled me, to say the least. In contrast, what Parker Palmer calls a “circle of trust” — another good metaphor for what I want to create as a mentor –
combines unconditional love, or regard, with hopeful expectancy, creating a space that both safeguards and encourages the inner journey. In such a space, we are freed to hear our own truth, touch what brings us joy, become self-critical about our faults, and take risky steps toward change — knowing that we will be accepted no matter what the outcome.
What I hope will happen with my two Quest partners is summed up well in one of the poems read at their first retreat:
Walk Slowly by Danna Faulds
It only takes a reminder to breathe,
a moment to be still, and just like that,
something in me settles, softens, makes
space for imperfection. The harsh voice
of judgment drops to a whisper and I
remember again that life isn’t a relay
race; that we will all cross the finish
line; that waking up to life is what we
were born for. As many times as I
forget, catch myself charging forward
without even knowing where I’m going,
that many times I can make the choice
to stop, to breathe, and be, and walk
slowly into the mystery.



Thank you for those inspirational words! I believe that spiritual direction requires clear thinking and relief from our quadmire of wars. To be a religious and/or spiritual person requires a heart full of love, mercy, and forgiveness. People need to be free and not slaves to a system ruled by monetary selfishness and a country carrying on endless wars.
Here are some words from Karen Kwiatkowski’s most recent article, “Afghanistan a Success – Time to Come Home!” She is a retired military officer.
Thinking people everywhere see our Afghanistan experience as a crash of 20th-century American empire on the 21st-century rocks of reality. The contraction of our empire – happening today in monetary as well as military terms – is at least a full generation overdue. The false sustenance of a financial bubble corresponds with the failing sustenance of military empire. Our children are the first generation who are not citizens, but Caesar’s slaves, bound to a life of fear and labor, made bearable only by their inchoate dreams of freedom. The military-industrial complex, a benign tumor in the days of Eisenhower, has metastasized to the extent that generals run Washington and the fourth estate exists solely to serve the imperial machine.
Obama has a small window of opportunity to declare victory and take a step towards retroactively earning his Nobel peace prize. Afghanistan no longer threatens us, and they’d like their country back.
I enjoyed your article as I have been in a spiritual direction relationship for over ten years. we do the work now over email because of distance but I am always free to meander whereever I want to. she is an anchor when I am floundering, a person who can point me to a book which is appropriate, and a person who loves me for the searcher that I am. Good luck and thankyou for the Palmer reference. I just spent two days with sandra butler and she describes Parker Palmer as a hero for her.
Hey Nancy – interesting thoughts. Having been through (and still somehow connected) to a Parker Palmer inspired Integration Group through Quest 1 at FUS (in Madison WI by the way) I have also been asked to be a mentor to a questy. To be honest, I feel complimented by the request and being told that I am a wise and compassionate guy, but personally, I do not feel at all comfortable with that. No mam – dumb as a post, that’s me. Full of human foibles, – in fact, I think I got extra – and constantly reminded of it by my daily life. So for me, when my one advisee shows up (if she does) I’m thinking we go bowling, or golfing, or rock climbing or some such. These are the things I do that regardless of others (especially Spiritual Directors and Mentors, which sound to me like snake-oil sales – sorry Marcia) get me to realize that I’m just a schlump who can’t hit the fairway very often, and if he does, is bound to three putt. I dunno – guy vs gal spirituality, eh? Well, keep on posting, kid. BTW, I agree PP is a hero.
Marcia and Harry –Thanks for your comments.
Marcia — I like the idea of being someone’s anchor, although I’m glad to hear that you float free where you want, Marcia. And resource person is something I love to play — here’s something interesting, what do you think? And unconditional love certainly seems to be a piece.
Harry, you undersell yourself. We’re all full of human foibles. As soon as we know that we’ve acquired some wisdom! There may be something to the guy vs gal spirituality you posit. I have spent years learning to support (from birth on, I think) rather than to challenge. And that has ended up meaning supporting myself as well.
Seems that most of us doing this work are closer to Parker Palmer’s approach than the “alternative” he describes – not that many traditionalists of all stripes aren’t out there promoting the alternative.
In that vein, folks use all kinds of labels like; “spiritual companion,” “spiritual friend,” “spiritual guide,” etc.
You might find interesting the diversity of descriptions of this process from folks of many faiths that is at Spiritual Directors International. None mention pressure, authority (other than the spirit in the person), or conformity.
http://www.sdiworld.org/what_is_spiritual_direction2.html
cheers,
Elena — I think you’re right that most spiritual directors function these days as spiritual companions or spiritual guides. I think ultimately it’s a semantic problem for me, but it was useful for me to understand why the “direction” part of spiritual direction grated so much for me. My experience with my first spiritual director was a little more directive than I expected, so maybe I’m reacting to that as well.
Thanks for the website. I’ll look it over when I get a chance.