NO, Mr. Netanyahu! We Will NOT Let You Drag the U.S. Into a Proxy War for Israel Against Iran — Sign the NY Times Ad

We invite you to sign and contribute financial support to make this New York Times ad possible (go to to sign and donate to make this ad possible).

Would you join us as a signer of the proposed full-page New York Timesad below? If so, please give us your name as you wish it to appear. You may also include a short institutional or organizational affiliation (for identification purposes only).

This ad will only be possible if you and others donate generously (please stretch a little) to make it possible. Donate Now. You may also view a PDF version of how the ad will roughly look when it is published in U.S and Israeli newspapers, and in online media.

No, Mr. Netanyahu— you do not speak for American Jews.

  • Every poll indicates that a majority of American Jews (and most non-Jews) support President Obama’s attempt to negotiate a settlement that would prohibit Iranian development of nuclear weapons rather than the Netanyahu approach of undermining those negotiations.
  • Every poll indicates that a majority of American Jews oppose the expansion of West Bank settlements that Netanyahu favors, and support the creation of an independent Palestinian state living in peace with Israel.

And… The American People Do Not Want a War with Iran!

Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu’s attempt to shape American foreign policy toward Iran is unwelcome. A poll in February showed 62% of Americans opposed the way that the Republican leadership had invited Netanyahu to speak.  Choosing to make his American visit a few days ahead of Israeli elections lead some to suspect that his visit is a tactic to help build support for his political party. Misleadingly, much of the media quotes “American Jewish leaders” who support Netanyahu—but those leaders are not elected by American Jews and the media should be quoting leaders who represent the majority sentiments of American Jews who have long been committed to peace and reconciliation with the Palestinian people.  While many of us hope to see the people of Iran non-violently work to transform Iranian society to foster democracy and human rights, we know that war with Iran will only strengthen the hold of the Islamic fundamentalists and decrease the security of Americans and of Jews around the world. So we oppose the efforts of some in Congress and the Netanyahu faction in Israel who together seek to derail negotiations with Iran.

We who sign this ad are American Jews and our non-Jewish allies who oppose any attempt to drag the American people into another war. We remember the way that the Bush Administration lied us into a war with Iraq by providing false information about a non-existent threat of Iraqi nuclear weapons. We do not need a repeat of that scenario as militarists in Israel and the U.S. once again use the fear of non-existent nuclear weapons to manipulate us into another war. It is not in the interests of the U.S., Israel or the people of the world.

The U.S. spent over a trillion dollars on the war in Iraq and Afghanistan. The outcome was to produce the Islamic State armed with weapons brought to the region by the U.S. The strategy of domination over those identified as “evil others” and used by the U.S. and Israel as the path to homeland security has not worked. Using force, violence, wars, bombings, torture, and coercion has been tried for the past five thousand years and it has not produced a world of peace or security. It is time to switch from full spectrum dominance to a Strategy of Generosity. That same trillion dollars could have been used to create a Global Marshall Plan that could have wiped out global and domestic poverty, homelessness, hunger, inadequate education and inadequate health care—thereby demonstrating to the world a U.S. that cares for the well-being of others.

The Islamic extremists and others who resort to violence would have a much harder time recruiting fighters and supporters to struggles against the West if we were known to the world (and Israel were known to the Palestinian people) through our generosity rather than through our military and economic power to dominate and advance the interests of our own corporations at the expense of everyone else, meanwhile humiliating traditional cultures and ancient religions. The “realists” scoff at such thinking—yet their strategies have continually failed for thousands of years.

So even while some of the signatories to this letter do not oppose the use of force in extreme circumstances like WWII or stopping ISIS/Islamic State, we do believe it’s time to give generosity and caring for others a real chance, not only because it is in our self-interest, but also because the capitalist ethos of materialism, selfishness, looking out for number one, and winning through intimidation has created distortions in our own society that are as destructive to us and our families as is the globalization of these values destructive to the lives of people around the world. It is time for what Jews call “tikkun”–healing and transformation–not for more wars and domination. Lets start now with a Global Marshall Plan!

Now it’s time for you to let your voice be heard. Show your support by signing below!

Please make a financial contribution if you want to see this ad appear in the NY Times and other U.S. and Israeli media. (But please be sure to still enter your information below and sign first).

Signatories (institutions listed only for identification purposes):

Rabbi Michael Lerner, Editor Tikkun Magazine
Peter Gabel, Editor at Large, Tikkun Magazine
Cat Zavis, Executive Director of the Network of Spiritual Progressives
Mark Levine, Professor of Political Science, UC Irvine
Dr. Aaron J. Hahn Tapper, Director Jewish Studies Program, University of San Francisco
Prof. Shaul Magid , Chair of Jewish Studies in Modern Judaism at Indiana University
Dr. Stephen Zunes, Professor of Politics and International Studies at the University of San Francisco
Dr. Phillip Wolfson, Psychiatrist, San Francisco
Prof. Cynthia Moe Lobeda, Author of Resisting Structural Evil: Love as Ecological-Economic Vocation
Dr. Deborah Kory, Psychologist
Josh Healey, Poet, Comedian, Community Organizer
Ana Levy-Lyons Unitarian Minister
Rabbi Sheila Peltz Weinberg
Peter Yarrow, of “Peter, Paul, and Mary”
Dr. Maynard Seider
Erik van Praag
Dr. Helen Fox, University of Michigan
Prof. Hasia R. Diner, New York University
Prof. Stuart Newman, NY Medical College
Barbara Green
Lester Grinspoon, M.D. Harvard Medical School
Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum
Estelle Frankel, Author Sacred Therapy
Prof. Jeffery Prager, Dept. of Sociology at UCLA
Jill Goldberg, Professor of English Literature & Creative Writing, Langara College, Vancouver
Rabbi. Aryeh Cohen, Professor of rabbinic literature at American Jewish University

Please add your name to the signatories of this ad and donate to make it happen. Anyone who donates $300 or  more will have their name listed on the ad itself, and there will be a link to the full list of hundreds of signatories who sign the ad. To sign and/or donate, go to

tags: US Politics   
Tip Jar Email Bookmark and Share RSS Print
Get Tikkun by Email -- FREE

COMMENT POLICY Please read our comments policy. We invite constructive disagreement but do not accept personal attacks and hateful comments. We reserve the right to block hecklers who repost comments that have been deleted. We do have automated spam filters that sometimes miscategorize legitimate comments as spam. If you don't see your comment within ten minutes, please click here to contact us. Due to our small staff it may take up to 48 hours to get your comment posted.

7 Responses to NO, Mr. Netanyahu! We Will NOT Let You Drag the U.S. Into a Proxy War for Israel Against Iran — Sign the NY Times Ad

  1. Ashok Vidwans February 27, 2015 at 9:20 am

    I fully agree with the above.

  2. Nofyah Shem Tov March 1, 2015 at 8:19 am

    Stupidity knows no limits. The US started the problem in Iran, and Obama is dragging the US into a war against Israel. You won’t get it until they come for you.

  3. Leonard Cohen March 2, 2015 at 8:36 am

    War is no a path to peace in the Middle East. Diplomacy may be!

  4. Robert Griffin March 2, 2015 at 8:45 am

    I agree. No more war.

  5. hophmi March 2, 2015 at 2:32 pm

    Your framing of this as Netanyahu dragging the US into a war is deeply antisemitic. If the US goes to war with Iran, it will be because the US wanted to go to war with Iran, and not because an Israeli Prime Minister “dragged” them there. While I’m not a fan of Netanyahu speaking before Congress, he’s making his case, and the United States can take it or leave it. The US is not some dog that the Jews pull on a leash, and the suggestion is abhorrent.

  6. Fred Little March 3, 2015 at 7:43 pm

    No war.

  7. Ghazal Omid March 6, 2015 at 3:41 pm

    I just read this article and it is amazing but I am not sure why would you need thousands of dollars for an advertisement to appear in NY times. As a 501c3 organization, I can place any advertisement in any paper for free (maybe not on the first page) and you can do the same as long as you have a valid 501c3

    I hope this eases your worries.

    All in all, great effort very much appreciated.


    Ghazal Omid

    Executive Director at Iran & Its

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *